Rubric

Essay 1 Rubric
Essay 1 Rubric
Criteria Ratings Pts
Focus/Thesis
threshold: pts
35 pts Outstanding: Essay presents a clearly focused idea that does not rely on plot summaries.
33 pts Strong
31 pts Commendable: Essay presents a strong sense of focus but needs better development.
28 pts Good work
26 pts Adequate: The essay's level of focus meets the basic requirements to pass.
23 pts Needs work
20 pts Inadequate: The essay shows only the most minimum amount of focus.
0 pts There is no sense of focus or purpose in this paper.
pts
35 pts
--
Organization
threshold: pts
25 pts Outstanding: The essay was organized well and clearly presented. There was a strong overall sense of flow to the writing.
23 pts Strong
21 pts Commendable: The material was well organized but could have been clearer. The thesis was not fully supported.
19 pts Good work
17 pts Adequate: The essay was not well organized and the writing lacked clarity. There was very little sense of purpose or direction to the writing.
15 pts Needs work: The essay felt more like a series of observations rather the development of a single idea.
11 pts Inadequate
0 pts The essay lacked any sense of organization or coherence. It was very difficult to follow.
pts
25 pts
--
Grammar/Clarity
threshold: pts
15 pts Essay effectively manages complex punctuation and grammar. The essay also shows an effective and skillful understanding of grammar.
13 pts The essay shows an effective and skillful understanding of grammar. Minor errors may exist but are not significant.
11 pts The essay demonstrates strong control of standard written English. Most sentences are complete, clear, and correctly structured.
9 pts Essay contains some grammar, spelling, or punctuation errors. While these errors are noticeable they are not distracting.
7 pts Essay contains some grammar, spelling, or punctuation errors. These errors are significant enough that it distracts the reader from understanding the essay.
0 pts The essay shows a lack of control over standard written English. Grammar, punctuation, and spelling errors make it very difficult to understand the essay.
pts
15 pts
--